Herbert Douglass’ contributions to Adventist thought are widely known through previous publications in book form (especially Messenger of the Lord, Pacific Press, 1998) and periodical articles, as well as numerous oral presentations.

Although initially this book deals with how to understand Ellen White’s several expressions that on the surface seem to militate against Christian confidence, hence its title, in fact Dr. Douglass wrestles with several other issues troubling to many Christians. His discussions on grace and obedience affirm the balance of both within an ellipse that preserves the value of the two in what theologians term truth in tension. From there he leads us through a series of questions, including legalism, perfectionism, and whether assurance can be lost. Throughout, his core theme rests on how true Christianity is identified with a surrendered walk with God, something beyond mere intellectual confession.

Herb Douglass has been criticized by some for his thinking with regard to perfection and the nature of the incarnate Christ. While he does not touch the second theme here, some will find his chapter on perfection surprisingly outside stereotypes. His treatment of the necessity of a pre-advent judgment is a defense of long-established Adventist beliefs and addresses the objections that some have directed to this doctrine.

Douglass’ reader-friendly informality avoids heavy theological language while dealing with weighty questions. The result is freshly readable. Tucked into the heart of the book is a chapter [14] that seems almost a unit apart, where he turns momentarily from his biblical theme to explore scientifically the way in which habits are developed. His purpose is to relate this process to moral choices in seeking to live a surrendered life. Many readers will find this discussion enlightening and encouraging. On another matter, his use of a series of expressions that have become virtual code words in one of the independent ministries, the 1888 Message Study Committee, will no doubt raise questions in the minds of some readers. Overall, this book will be helpful for an array of Adventists who wrestle with the questions he is addressing.